Improving LW
balise2001 <aunumero13@...>
Hi all !
First, excuse my approximate english... I'm new to the list :-) Following Gary's advice, I purchased a PL-310 a few days ago and I'm really pleased with its FM performance. However, as an NDB DX'er (1900 NDB from 92 DXCC countries heard so far), I'm a bit disappointed with the result on LW. I barely hear the french powerful longwave broadcasters (France Inter, RMC) and of course it's even more difficult to catch these low-power beacons in the 280-450 kHz range. Yet, I would try to play with my Tecsun and catch as many NDB as possible. It can be funny. I read about a loopstick, but I'm unable to build one. Are there 'ready-to-use' models that fit the PL-310 ? Where can I order one from, what price ? If not, how can I simply improve reception on LW (or on MW if it's easier, since I also enjoy MW DX'ing). I wish you all a great and peaceful new year. Thanks a lot for your advices, tips or comments. Regards, Patrick - South-east France.
|
|
|
|
Henk_Verdru
Hi Patrick,
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
veuillez excuser mon anglais approximatif ;-) I live close to the French border in Belgium and normally I can listen without any problem to France Inter, RTL, BBC Radio4, Europe1 and RMC on my different LW-capable Radios. However the Tecsuns (I have a PL-380 and a PL-390) are a bit disappointing on LW (by contrast, on MW and SW they are very good). To improve Long Wave reception I use a Q-Stick (http://www.dxtools.com/QStick.htm). The gain on LW is *spectacular* (even on my Sony SRF-M37L, which is the best LW-Ultralight I have), but less so on MW (I find the Terk Advantage better on MW). Regards, Henk (Kortrijk - Belgium)
--- In ultralightdx@..., "balise2001" <aunumero13@...> wrote:
|
|
|
|
balise2001 <aunumero13@...>
Many thanks for tip Henk !
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
This 'Q-Stick' seems fine... is this ferrite rod only avaible from R+ in Florida or is it possible to order in Europe ? It shows an 'ext ant' jack ; What is the point of using such an accessory with an external antenna ? (Sorry for the stupid question...) Your english is very fine ;-) Patrick
--- In ultralightdx@..., "Henk_Verdru" <henk.verdru@...> wrote:
|
|
|
|
Hi Patrick,
Thanks for your message, and also for your private emails concerning the
PL-310 (your questions will be answered privately, soon).
Concerning the LW-design 7.5" loopsticks for the Tecsun DSP models, I have
developed a sensitive LW loopstick with a plug-in style connector, designed
to fit the Tecsun PL-360 model (which has a loopstick plug-in jack). Detailed
experimentation was run with five different LW loopstick designs (pictured at http://www.mediafire.com/i/?iv32u55b1ieyd5p ),
and I am personally using the "E" model (a 1900 uh coil of 100/45 Litz wire on a
Type 33 ferrite bar) for NDB reception. So far, I have logged NDB stations in 5
states and 4 Canadian provinces with this 7.5" loopstick, including a 250w
station in the Canadian province of Manitoba (248-WG). This particular
design has sensitive coverage of the LW broadcast band (153-279 kHz) and the NDB
frequencies up to about 450 kHz. So far, I've taken about 15 orders for these LW
loopsticks, but could make one more for you, Patrick, if you are willing to
wait.
Although the 7.5" LW loopsticks were designed for the PL-360
model, they will work with any Tecsun DSP Ultralight radio once the
circuitry is modified to accept the loopstick in place of the stock ferrite bar.
The PL-310 external antenna connector can be rewired to accomplish this (the
Laurie Mann modification), and my own Longwave NDB chaser is a modified PL-380,
with a cabinet attachment to accept the LW and MW 7.5" plug-in loopsticks
(pictured below).
73 and Good DX,
Gary DeBock (in Puyallup, WA, USA)
In a message dated 1/10/2011 11:37:58 A.M. Pacific Standard Time,
aunumero13@... writes:
|
|
|
|
Russ Edmunds <wb2bjh@...>
--- On Mon, 1/10/11, balise2001 wrote:
|
|
|
|
Russ Edmunds <wb2bjh@...>
--- On Mon, 1/10/11, balise2001 wrote:
|
|
|
|
Henk_Verdru
--- In ultralightdx@..., Russ Edmunds <wb2bjh@...> wrote:
Correct, but this rule doesn't explain why the Tecsuns underperform on LW in comparison with e.g. Sony's SRF-M37L (even with all its shortcomings) which has a shorter antenna. Henk
|
|
|
|
Henk_Verdru
--- In ultralightdx@..., "balise2001" <aunumero13@...> wrote:
Quoting the dxtools-website, the "ext ant" jack is used "to optimally couple the signal from an external antenna to a portable radio's front-end circuitry". But, personally, I only use the Q-Stick through inductive coupling "by placing it in close proximity to the radio." Henk
|
|
|
|
balise2001 <aunumero13@...>
I checked reception on LW, yesterday at 22z with my TECSUN PL-310 :
153 : traces 162 : weak to fair 171 : traces to nil 177 : traces 183 : good 189 : nil 198 : traces 207 : weak 216 : fair 225 : traces 234 : good 252 : fair I did not check 261-270 and 279. This is very poor assuming I live in a (quiet) rural area. Using a Degen de1103, from the same place of course, I was able to dig out 171-Morocco at local noon. Regarding NDB : a single one is audible, located 15 km from home.
|
|
|
|
balise2001 <aunumero13@...>
Hi Gary,
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Many thanks for your kind reply (as usual !) Your LW-design loopstick also looks fine and effective but it seems one has to modify the receiver in order to use it, right ? The problem is I'm not a technie, and I don't want to open and tinker with the radio... actually, I do not feel competent to do this meticulous work. Thus, I would probably be wiser to order a ready-to-use antenna such as the Q-stick Henk has recommanded. Patrick
--- In ultralightdx@..., D1028Gary@... wrote:
|
|
|
|
Rik
I have both Gary's LW and MW antennas for the PL-360. They plug right into the external antenna jack to replace the tiny little one from the factory. I also have the Q-stick which couples to any ferrite antenna in a radio. The jack on the Q-stick allows me to plug a long wire or Beverage antenna into the jack, and use the Q-stick to couple the signal from the wire antenna to the ferrite antenna inside a radio. None of those set ups require any modification of the radio it self. - FARMERIK
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
--- In ultralightdx@..., "balise2001" <aunumero13@...> wrote:
|
|
|
|
Charly <calpublic@...>
Hi everyone, et bonjour aux francophones, I've tested LW this morning from the Paris area with my PL-390 (with a longer loopstick than the PL-310 ?) : - 162 : very good - 234 : very good Nothing else so far, only a few mumble sometime but not possible to identified. Very disappointing, but I did not buy it for LW so I don't mind. It was the first time I switched my radio to LW ;-). In MW I can catch most of western Europe (didn't try DX so far). By the way, on the PL-390, the antenna input jack is labeled "SW ant". Does this mean that the internal loopstick remains active when the radio is used for MW & LW ? Best regards, Charly -------------------------------------- From: balise2001 Date: Tue, 11 Jan 2011 12:55:24 -0000 To: ultralightdx@... Cc: Subject: [ultralightdx] Re: Improving LW
I checked reception on LW, yesterday at 22z with my TECSUN PL-310 : 153 : traces 162 : weak to fair 171 : traces to nil 177 : traces 183 : good 189 : nil 198 : traces 207 : weak 216 : fair 225 : traces 234 : good 252 : fair I did not check 261-270 and 279. This is very poor assuming I live in a (quiet) rural area. Using a Degen de1103, from the same place of course, I was able to dig out 171-Morocco at local noon. Regarding NDB : a single one is audible, located 15 km from home. ------------------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Links <*> To visit your group on the web, go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ultralightdx/ <*> Your email settings: Individual Email | Traditional <*> To change settings online go to: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ultralightdx/join (Yahoo! ID required) <*> To change settings via email: ultralightdx-digest@... ultralightdx-fullfeatured@... <*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to: ultralightdx-unsubscribe@... <*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
|
|
|
|
balise2001 <aunumero13@...>
Hi Farmerik, Thanks for your comments. I may be wrong due to my limited english, but what I understood is that Gary's loopsticks don't need any mod' ONLY when used with a PL-360. Gary wrote : "Although the 7.5" LW loopsticks were designed for the PL-360 model, they will work with any Tecsun DSP Ultralight radio once the circuitry is modified to accept the loopstick in place of the stock ferrite bar. The PL-310 external antenna connector can be rewired to accomplish this (...)" Regards, Patrick, south-east France
--- In ultralightdx@..., "farmerik" wrote: > > I have both Gary's LW and MW antennas for the PL-360. They plug right into the external antenna jack to replace the tiny little one from the factory. I also have the Q-stick which couples to any ferrite antenna in a radio. The jack on the Q-stick allows me to plug a long wire or Beverage antenna into the jack, and use the Q-stick to couple the signal from the wire antenna to the ferrite antenna inside a radio. None of those set ups require any modification of the radio it self. - FARMERIK > > --- In ultralightdx@..., "balise2001" aunumero13@ wrote: > > > > Hi Gary, > > > > Many thanks for your kind reply (as usual !) > > > > Your LW-design loopstick also looks fine and effective but it seems one has to modify the receiver in order to use it, right ? > > The problem is I'm not a technie, and I don't want to open and tinker with the radio... actually, I do not feel competent to do this meticulous work. > > > > Thus, I would probably be wiser to order a ready-to-use antenna such as the Q-stick Henk has recommanded. > > > > Patrick > > > > > > --- In ultralightdx@..., D1028Gary@ wrote: > > > > > > Hi Patrick, > > > > > > Thanks for your message, and also for your private emails concerning the > > > PL-310 (your questions will be answered privately, soon). > > > > > > Concerning the LW-design 7.5" loopsticks for the Tecsun DSP models, I have > > > developed a sensitive LW loopstick with a plug-in style connector, designed > > > to fit the Tecsun PL-360 model (which has a loopstick plug-in jack). > > > Detailed experimentation was run with five different LW loopstick designs > > > (pictured at _http://www.mediafire.com/i/?iv32u55b1ieyd5p_ > > > (http://www.mediafire.com/i/?iv32u55b1ieyd5p) ), and I am personally using the "E" model (a 1900 > > > uh coil of 100/45 Litz wire on a Type 33 ferrite bar) for NDB reception. So > > > far, I have logged NDB stations in 5 states and 4 Canadian provinces with > > > this 7.5" loopstick, including a 250w station in the Canadian province of > > > Manitoba (248-WG). This particular design has sensitive coverage of the LW > > > broadcast band (153-279 kHz) and the NDB frequencies up to about 450 kHz. So > > > far, I've taken about 15 orders for these LW loopsticks, but could make > > > one more for you, Patrick, if you are willing to wait. > > > > > > Although the 7.5" LW loopsticks were designed for the PL-360 model, they > > > will work with any Tecsun DSP Ultralight radio once the circuitry is > > > modified to accept the loopstick in place of the stock ferrite bar. The PL-310 > > > external antenna connector can be rewired to accomplish this (the Laurie Mann > > > modification), and my own Longwave NDB chaser is a modified PL-380, with a > > > cabinet attachment to accept the LW and MW 7.5" plug-in loopsticks > > > (pictured below). > > > > > > 73 and Good DX, > > > Gary DeBock (in Puyallup, WA, USA) > > >
|
|
|
|
balise2001 <aunumero13@...>
Bonjour Charly !
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
It's about the same here (near Chambery) under daylight conditions. Only 162, 183, 216 and 234 are audible (both France Inter and RMC being pretty weak). I did not purchase this unit for its LW abilities neither, but I would still improve its sensitivity to catch some NDBs in the 280-500 kHz range. MW is far better (though it's a powerful station, Saudi Arabia on 1521 is an easy catch in the evening). Just for fun, I also intend to catch the largest number of MW stations. Regards, Patrick
--- In ultralightdx@..., Charly <calpublic@...> wrote:
|
|
|
|
Kevin Schanilec
Bonjour, Patrick:
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
C'est vrai! The PL-310 needs a modification, while the PL-360 has a built-in antenna jack that will accept the external antenna. The PL-360 is the only Ultralight (s0 far) that has this feature. The PL-310 modification is quite an easy one if you have any soldering skills, or would not be a huge imposition on a friend that does have soldering skills :-) See "PL-310 External LW MW Antenna Mod.pdf" in Folder 6, "Alignment and Modification" here on the Group. Regards - Kevin
--- In ultralightdx@..., "balise2001" <aunumero13@...> wrote:
|
|
|
|
balise2001 <aunumero13@...>
Thanks for this info Russ.
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Well, I suppose similar products can be found in Europe as well ! If EU members can help, and recommand a good 'Q-stick' style antenna available here... TIA. Patrick
--- In ultralightdx@..., Russ Edmunds <wb2bjh@...> wrote:
|
|
|
|
Russ Edmunds <wb2bjh@...>
--- On Tue, 1/11/11, balise2001 wrote:
|
|
|
|
Steve Ratzlaff <steveratz@...>
Hi Henk,
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
Where do you obtain the SRF-M37L? I'm not familiar with that model, with the LF? Steve
----- Original Message -----
From: "Henk_Verdru" <henk.verdru@...> To: <ultralightdx@...> Sent: Tuesday, January 11, 2011 2:57 AM Subject: [ultralightdx] Re: Improving LW
|
|
|
|
Kevin Schanilec
Hey Steve/all:
toggle quoted messageShow quoted text
I tried in the past to buy a M37L, but they are apparently only available in Europe, primarily in the UK, where they go for about $45 US plus whatever the shipping would be. KK Electronics claims to ship from the UK to the USA - I have an email into them just for kicks to see what it would cost overall. The manual is here: pdf.crse.com/manuals/3249146131.pdf Unfortunately, the M37L only tunes 153-279 khz, which misses most of the NDB band here. Also, the tuning step is 9 khz, so even with the very wide filtering, the NDB coverage would be even more spotty. Kevin
--- In ultralightdx@..., "Steve Ratzlaff" <steveratz@...> wrote:
|
|
|
|
Henk_Verdru
--- In ultralightdx@..., "Steve Ratzlaff" <steveratz@...> wrote:
Hi Steve, the M37L is a European version (I guess) of the M37W with longwave in stead of the weather band. I bought one in 2007 in a Sony Centre in Belgium (for about 70 euros) and another one on Ebay (annanovauk, a UK-seller) for about 50 euros (+ P&P), last year. Right now on Ebay, "annovafr" (or annovauk) is offering a M37L for about 60 euros (+ P&P) The main disadvantage of this radio (apart from the known selectivity problems of the M37W) is its limitation to a 9 or 10 khz AM tuning scheme, which means I have to listen to Europe1 on 180khz in stead of 183khz. Henk
|
|
|