I saw the announcement a few months ago about a number of
new Degen small radios. The new DE221 caught my attention. I’ve been waiting
for someone to buy one and report their observations. Not seeing this, I
decided to buy one and give it a quick evaluation.
The DE221 is an upgrade of the Degen DE321 AM, FM and SW low
cost small radio. Both are based on the Silicon Labs DSP chip. The major
difference is that the DE321 is entirely looking like an old style mechanically
tuned radio. The DE221, even though
based on the same DSP technology, it has most of the appearance and operation
of a low end digital AM (MW), FM, and SW radio.
Some major points of the DE221
· - Is a little smaller and thinner than the popular
PL380. Pocketable.
· - Digital display (non-backlit) of frequency, mode
(I.e. MW, FM or SW) time, alarm, sleep
timer and battery strength
· -Tuning is via a rotary control on the right
side. The band is selected by a top mounted slider band switch (FM1, FM2, MW
and 8 SW bands)
· - As the band is tuned, a mechanical pointer on
the right side of the front case moves from a value of 0 at the bottom to a 10
at the top. Think of this as a sort of band spread indication to show generally
where you are in a band.
· - As you tune, the digital display is showing the
tuned frequency, in megahertz FM and SW and kilohertz MW. -There is a small and
sensitive “Tune” LED that comes on when a station is exactly tuned in
· - Volume is a rotary control on the right .. good
speaker volume and good headphone sound
· -There are 8 buttons with all legends in Chinese.
But they are simple enough. The buttons from 1 to 8, from left to right and from
top to bottom are:
1 – Stereo / mono for FM
2 – Alarm off / on (only when powered
off). Alarm turns on the radio to last station tuned in.
3 – Set current time or alarm time
hours (only when powered off)
4 – Select sleep timer minutes (steps
from 90 to off with each press) and turns on the radio
5 – Set the current time (press and
hold until display blinks, only when powered off)
6 – Set the alarm time (press and hold
until display blinks, only when powered off)
7 - Set current time or alarm time
minutes (only when powered off)
8 – Radio power on / off
· - - Powered by 2 AA batteries or external 5 VDC. No
feature to recharge batteries.
· - Stereo headphone jack and a lock switch on the
left side.
So how does it work?
·
In general the tuning control takes maybe two
complete revolutions to span a band. So the tuning is not as difficult or ‘touchy’
as the DE321. The tuning seems smooth though mine seems to slip some. Time will
tell if this is a chronic problem. I had
to take the radio apart and apply some auto belt conditioner to add a little
grip to the dial cord (string, really) used inside. It has helped so far. The
“tune” led comes on when a stronger station is tuned spot on say 88.1 not 88.0
or 88.2.
·
FM: good sensitivity and reasonable selectivity. Tunes in 100 khz
increments. A given station can be heard even if the indicated frequency in the
display is off by plus or minus a few hundred khz. Stereo in head phones. The
DE221 heard almost all of the FM stations that my PL380 did. So FM performance
is excellent.
·
MWMW: Poor sensitivity and selectivity. Touchy to
tune to get exactly on the desired frequency. However the tuning is so broad,
per the display, that you can receive the station even if the display indicates
the frequency 20 or more kilohertz plus or minus from the actual frequency. So
it’s easy to tune. Only tunes to 1620 khz. Only good for the medium and stronger local
stations. The ferrite bar antenna looks to be just short of two inches long. The muting / volume reduction seems aggressive such that turning up the volume for a weak station may well blast you when you tune through a stronger station.
·
SW: Tunes in 5 khz increments. Same broad tuning of a station as above for MW
stations. Very sensitive off whip but burdened by some garble from the local MW
stations on some SW bands. It was able to hear almost all of the SW stations
that the PL380 did. Plus this tunes very much like an analog type of radio …
meaning that you can fairly quickly scan across a band looking for stations.
Overall, decent SW performance.
Summary
For a just over $20 price point the DE221 is just ok
performance wise. The FM performance is very good and makes the DE221 acceptable
for the price. SW performance is ok but MW is so-so. And this is assuming
that my DE221 slipping tuning control is not an issue with all DE221’s. Overall I feel there are other receivers at
the price point with better overall performance. I’ve compared the DE221 to the
PL380 that costs twice the price of the DE221 but the performance and features comparison
is like night and day in favor of the PL380.
Gary KE8WO